Posts Tagged ‘sector’

Posted by Moshe Alexander

The vacancy rate among apartments with at least three units (3+) in the Thunder Bay Census Metropolitan Area (CMA) inched up to 2.3 per cent in October 2009, from 2.2 per cent last year, according to Rental Market Survey (RMS) data released in December by Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation (CMHC). (See Table 1.1.1) With the October vacancy rate’s slight increase, Thunder Bay now becomes the CMA with the tenth lowest vacancy rate for 33 centres with populations over 100,000 in Canada. Northern Ontario’s other major centre, Sudbury saw its rate rise to 2.9 per cent from 0.7 per cent last year. Meanwhile, elsewhere in Northwestern Ontario, Kenora’s vacancy rate declined to 0.8 per cent from 1.7 per cent in October 2008.

The vacancy rate in Thunder Bay was up only slightly this year as several opposing forces came into play. Improvement in homeownership affordability caused by falling interest rates has encouraged some renters to become homeowners. Low ownership costs in Thunder Bay combined with rising apartment rents reduced the relative cost of homeownership – dampening demand for rental accommodation. There are other factors that have added to rental demand and exerted downward pressure on vacancy rates. Although there has been a long-term out-migration amongst the 18 to 24 renter aged group, important trends emerged recently. Employment in the service sector and 18-24 age groups have held up reasonably well, possibly exerting slight upward pressure on rental demand, as young adults are more likely to rent rather than own. Overall, employment has fallen 5.5 per cent over the past year between the 2008 and 2009 surveys. However, the brunt of the job losses has been in the goods-producing sector and the 25-44 age group, arguably sectors not directly associated with rental demand. Next, demand coming from students in post-secondary institutions has increased rental demand. Enrolment in post-secondary institutions has been growing in Thunder Bay. Less space in student housing has caused spillover in the private market creating demand for units located in proximity to Lakehead University and Confederation College. Laid off workers returning to school as mature students are creating additional demand for private rentals. In addition, recent data has indicated no new sources of rental supply. Going back to 1998, there have been few rental completions added to the supply of rental units in Thunder Bay.

The availability rate1 is a slightly broader measure of what landlords have available to market to prospective tenants. The availability rate refers to the percentage of apartments that are either vacant or for which the existing tenant has given or received notice to move. Once again, availability rates moved in the same direction as the vacancy rate in Thunder Bay. Thunder Bay’s availability rate rose to 3.1 per cent from 2.7 per cent in 2008. Only one of the 15 metropolitan areas in Ontario had a lower availability rate than Thunder Bay, namely Kingston (2.5 per cent). Higher availability rates are a result of higher turnover. (See Table 1.4.)

Posted by Moshe Alexander

A number of factors have exerted upward pressure on Sudbury’s vacancy rate. Between October 2008 and October 2009, employment in the mining and related service sector has fallen. The challenges facing global demand for stainless steel have impacted Sudbury’s nickel industry and services related specifically to this sector. While the latest migration results (2007-2008) for Sudbury CMA showed positive net in-migration for the sixth consecutive year, it is more likely that in-migration slowed as well since last fall due to less investment spending in the mining industry. Some of these residents affected by the changing fortunes of the nickel market, may have left Sudbury to find work causing the vacancy rate to rise if they resided in rental housing. Meanwhile, a slowing job market triggered less renter household formation, particularly among the core renter group of young adults aged 18-24, resulting in more young adults remaining in the parental home.

Another factor dampening rental demand has been the shift to homeownership. An improvement of homeownership affordability caused by falling interest rates has prompted some renters to become homeowners over the past year. Although overall sales are lower, affordable priced product is moving well suggesting first time buyers are active.

With the total stock increasing only marginally over the course of the year, changes in the vacancy rate are attributable to changes in rental market demand, rather than fluctuations in supply. There is only a slight change in the rental universe observed between October 2008 and 2009 underlining the lack of new supply or changes to the stock of rental units (See Table 1.1.3). There have been only 58 rental completions in the last ten years according to CMHC’s survey in Greater Sudbury, with 31 coming last year. While the overall vacancy rate climbed to 2.9 per cent, both one bedroom and two bedroom units saw vacancy rates rise by a similar magnitude. Sudbury’s one bedroom stock saw its vacancy rate rise to 2.8 cent from 0.9 per cent while the two bed apartment stock jumped to 2.5 per cent compared to 0.4 per cent last year. Units in direct competition with homeownership saw an increase in vacancy rates as young couples and/or unattached singles move from rental units into homeownership or leave the community altogether.

Posted by Moshe Alexander

The rental market eased in the Trois- Rivières CMA this year. According to the results of the Rental Market Survey conducted in October by Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation (CMHC), the proportion of unoccupied units reached 2.7 per cent, compared to 1.7 per cent in the fall of 2008. In so doing, the vacancy rate surpassed the 2-per-cent mark for the first time since 2002. This increase, the third in as many years and the largest, reflects a certain easing of the market. In fact, since 2003, rental market conditions had been particularly tight in the Trois- Rivières area, with the proportion of vacant units hovering around 1.5 per cent. It should be noted however average for the last 20 years (5 per cent). In the fall of 2009, 435 units were vacant (compared to 273 in October 2008) out of a total stock of 16,276 apartments contained in privately initiated buildings with three or more housing units. Many new units and a

The low vacancy rates registered in the area for the past several years greatly stimulated rental housing construction. Until now, this additional supply had been just counterbalanced by the strong demand, which was attributable to the dynamic migration. In 2009, however, rental housing construction maintained the same pace, but demand declined slightly. The weaker job market in the Trois- Rivières area therefore removed the upward pressure on rental housing demand. For one thing, the economic uncertainty that has been looming over Trois-Rivières for several quarters has forced some workers to leave this area for another. At the same time, this economic environment has made the area less attractive in the eyes of job seekers from other areas. Consequently, the supply of housing units exceeded demand, which pushed up the vacancy rate. In addition, financing conditions, which have rarely been so favourable, prompted a few renter households to access homeownership. Given the low mortgage rates, some may even have moved up their decision to buy, which, in turn, vacated a few rental dwellings.

In October 2009, stable rental market conditions were noted in four of the six CMAs in the province, as the Québec, Gatineau, Montréal and Saguenay areas did not register any significant change in their vacancy rates compared to October 2008. This past October, the Sherbrooke CMA had the highest vacancy rate in the province (3.9 per cent), followed by Trois-Rivières (2.7 per cent), Montréal (2.5 per cent), Gatineau (2.2 per cent), Saguenay (1.5 per cent) and Québec (0.6 per cent).

While the vacancy rates went up in all sectors of the CMA, Downtown and Bécancour stood out. In fact, these two zones, which had the highest vacancy rates in the CMA, were responsible for the increase in the overall vacancy rate. In October 2009, the proportions of unoccupied units reached 5.0 per cent in the Downtown zone and 9.1 per cent in Bécancour. When the market eases, the Downtown zone is quite often the first to see its vacancy rate rise. This is due to the fact that its housing stock is older. It has been noted that, as units are vacated in other sectors of the CMA, tenants leave their Downtown dwellings for these units, which are often newer and more modern. In Bécancour, the market seems to have been experiencing difficulties since the closing of a plant in this zone. However, the upcoming commissioning of the Twin Rivers Technologies oilseed crushing plant and the construction of a complex for the production of polycrystalline silicon for the solar panel industry in the industrial and harbour park should give a boost to this zone and put upward pressure on housing demand there.

Elsewhere in the CMA, the vacancy rates remained relatively low. The proportions of unoccupied units reached 2.5 per cent in Cap-de-la- Madeleine and Saint-Louis-de-France and 2.1 per cent in the Université du Québec à Trois-Rivières sector, where demand for rental housing stays relatively constant in any given year, thanks to the presence of the university and the Cegep. Lastly, the vacancy rates attained 2.0 per cent in the North sector and 1.6 per cent in Trois-Rivières-Ouest.